People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The 2 of us had a whole vege pizza with broccoli on top. Devine. The base had a nice crunch to it and there was plenty of toppings. Very reasonable too. Didn't have to wait too long and had 2 slices left over. ”
“ This is my go to pizza spot when I’m in New York, and they never disappoint! Very flavourful and affordable slices. I usually take mine to go, and eat it a few blocks down with a view of the Brooklyn bridge ”
“ Nice big selection of pies. Good sauce and flavors. The crust is neither thin or thick, but has an airy, light but crunchy feel. The prices are not outrageous like most of Manhattan, but more in line with outer boros and Long Island, maybe even cheaper. Counter guys are nice. I like the bright red tiled walls in the dining area. Convenient to South Street Seaport. ”
“ When exploring around the seaport stop in for a quick bite to eat at Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli. Plenty of choices and the crispiest crusts of all the pizzas in NYC. Excellent. There is a also a nice inside area to sit and eat. No issues. Great pizza. ”
“ The Sicilian Pepperoni slice here looked appetizing, so I tried one. It's overflowing with scrumptious pepperoni, the sauce is great, the cheese is fantastic, and the crust at the end was very good. All factors of the slice were perfect. Try it! ”
“ Simple, delicious NY style pizza. If you are thinking of that thin, crispy and chewy crust, with a hint of sweetness sauce, and perfectly salty pepperoni, this is the spot. You have to get it fresh out of the oven! ”
“ Simply awesome, loved their CRUST, so many pizzas to choose from, i went with a slice of the vodka pie and they didnt disappoint... the cheese was very good, sauce was just as i expected... will visit again.. ”
“ If you’re craving authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than Little Italy Pizza! Located in the heart of New York, this pizzeria delivers everything you’d expect from a classic slice and more. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, yet has just the right amount of chewiness to hold up the generous toppings. Whether you’re a fan of a simple, cheesy Margherita or love piling on toppings like pepperoni and veggies, each slice is packed with flavor. The sauce is tangy, the cheese is gooey, and the fresh ingredients take it to the next level. One of the things I loved most is the welcoming, no-frills vibe of the place. It’s bustling with locals and tourists alike, and the staff is always friendly and quick with your order. Plus, they have an amazing variety – from classic pies to specialty options like white pizza or Grandma’s slice. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite on-the-go or sitting down for a casual meal, Little Italy Pizza never disappoints. If you’re a pizza lover in NYC, this place should be at the top of your list! ”
Menu
French Fries
US$3.99White (Slice)
US$5.45Cheese (Pie)
US$25.00Buffalo Chicken (Pie)
US$30.00Chicken Ricotta (Pie)
US$30.00
About
Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli
When in the heart of New York City, one must indulge in the delightful offerings at Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli, located at 50 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038. This charming eatery has quickly become a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike, thanks to its brilliant combination of flavor, quality, and affordability.
At Little Italy, the experience begins with the enticing aroma wafting from the kitchen. The star of the show? Their pizzas, which boast a perfectly balanced crust—neither too thin nor too thick—creating that ideal crunchy, airy texture that pizza aficionados crave. Customers rave about the variety of toppings available; one standout is the vegetarian pizza topped with hearty broccoli, enjoyed by Marina van Dijk. She described it as “devine,” highlighting the generous toppings and the crunchy base, a testament to the pizza's quality and a great value for money.
Returning patrons like Jas Woods proclaim Little Italy to be their go-to spot, further emphasizing the consistent flavor and affordability found in every slice. Many choose to grab their pizzas to go, enjoying their meal with a stunning view of the Brooklyn Bridge just a few blocks away. Little Italy embraces this experience, ensuring that every diner can savor their delicious food amidst the vibrant city backdrop.
The pizzeria’s specialty pies, such as the Sicilian Pepperoni slice highlighted by Christopher Zan, are overflowing with rich flavors. Reviewers praise the "scrumptious" pepperoni, a well-balanced sauce, and high-quality cheese, creating a medley of tastes that delivers satisfaction with every bite. Additionally, the comments on the bright red-tiled dining area reflect a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for both quick lunches and leisurely dinners.
Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli stands out not just for its delectable menu but also for its impressive affordability. As gary a. wexler noted, the pricing is refreshingly reasonable, particularly amidst the often inflated costs of Manhattan dining. This makes it a viable option for those seeking exceptional pizza without breaking the bank.
If you're exploring around South Street Seaport, don't miss the opportunity to stop in at Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli. With a vast selection of pies that promise the crispiest crust in NYC, you’re guaranteed an excellent meal. Whether you choose to enjoy your pizza in-house or on the go, you’ll leave with a satisfied palate and a happy heart.
Book a table